Macy’s $151M lesson for your balance sheet
Macy's found $151 million in erroneous entries that had been building up for years. How a balance sheet drifts away from reality at high volume, and how to keep every balance tied to the transactions behind it.

Most finance teams know an account like this. The balance has been there for months. It reconciles on paper, because at some point someone booked an entry that made it reconcile. Nobody has looked at what sits underneath it since.
Large misstatements can grow that way. Not from one wrong number, but from entries nobody questions.
Two recent cases
Macy’s uncovered $151 million in erroneous bookkeeping entries that had been building up since late 2021. The company chose not to restate its earlier financial statements, arguing that the errors did not materially affect its key metrics. The case sparked a debate among finance professionals about materiality. It also showed how long errors can sit in the books before anyone sees them.
Direct Line, a major motor insurer, disclosed an accounting mistake that overstated its financial strength. An internal review found that its solvency capital ratio had been reported at 197%. In reality, it was 188%. The difference exposed weaknesses in its financial controls.
Both cases come down to the same thing. A number on the balance sheet stopped reflecting reality, and the controls did not catch it in time.
How a balance drifts
For a company with millions of transactions across order systems, payment providers and an ERP, a balance can drift in several ways.
- The data is split. Every transaction passes through several systems, each with its own format and timing, so differences are bound to appear.
- Timing. A payment is recorded in one system but has not settled in another yet. The imbalance is temporary, but it is confusing.
- Suspense accounts become black holes. Unresolved mismatches are parked there and stay for months.
- Compliance becomes reactive. Without a current view of the balance sheet, you find out about problems after the fact.
The longer a mismatch stays unresolved, the harder it gets to untangle. Left alone, these problems do not just persist. They compound.
Jens Baarveld, CFO of MultiTankcard, describes what was at stake for his company. "We needed a way to match millions of transactions across fuel, EV charging, and public transport, without the constant risk of double invoicing or financial uncertainty."
Keep every balance tied to transactions
Checking every balance sheet item at month end does not hold up at high transaction volumes. What does hold up is keeping each balance connected to the transactions behind it, all month long.
- One source of truth. Order, payment and accounting data come together in one view, instead of in separate exports.
- Differences flagged as they happen. Anomalies are categorised right away, so the suspense account is no longer the temporary fix.
- Continuous reconciliation. Mismatches are found and resolved when they occur, not in a sprint at the close.
- Aggregate entries built from real transactions. Each booked total rests on the transactional data underneath it.
Freddy Dijkman, CFO of Recharge.com, puts the effect simply. "Now that Actuals automates reconciliation, our team can focus on resolving issues instead of getting bogged down in the process itself."
Trust starts on the balance sheet
Investors, auditors and executives use the financial statements to judge how healthy a company is. If the finance team cannot stand behind its numbers with confidence, that affects everything from strategic decisions to valuations.
Actuals helps high-transaction companies keep that confidence. Matching is automated, the suspense account stays clear, and every recorded number has proof behind it.
The Actuals scan takes 15 minutes and shows where your orders and your books first stop matching.
Sources
- Macy’s, disclosure of erroneous bookkeeping entries since late 2021
- Direct Line, disclosure of an overstated solvency capital ratio


